Every December, people inevitably have the same conversation: should we use a real or artificial Christmas tree? There’s a consistent idea that fake Christmas trees are better for the environment, as well as being more convenient. But is it really the more sustainable choice? Find out below.
Real vs Artificial Tree – What to Choose?
At first glance, artificial Christmas trees seem like a great option – they’re convenient, reusable, and save cutting down real trees, which can feel wasteful and harmful to nature. But are artificial trees as green as we think, or are real trees actually the more eco-friendly option? Let’s dive in and clear up the confusion.
Which is more environmentally harmful?
If you’re worried about the environmental impact of cutting down too many trees for the holidays, here’s some good news: about 30 million trees are cut down for Christmas per year, but there are about 350 to 500 million growing on farms at any given time. When you buy a real tree, you’re supporting these sustainable tree farms, helping preserve forest habitats and protecting wildlife.
It’s also important to remember that artificial trees are primarily made out of plastic. The manufacturing and shipping of these fake trees contribute heavily to global carbon emissions, while real trees actively absorb carbon. So, while using an artificial tree might save a real tree from being cut down, it still negatively impacts the environment.
Which is more wasteful?
Then there’s the issue of what to do with the tree after Christmas. Artificial trees are rarely recyclable, which means that once they reach the end of their life, they end up in landfills. While the idea is that we can use the tree forever, people might throw them out because the lights no longer work, they’ve upgraded to a bigger and better tree, or because they’re moving – there are lot’s of reasons to consider.
In comparison, there are donation options for real Christmas trees that contribute to conservation. Check with your local government for policies in your area. Even if you were to trash your real tree, at the very least it is compostable.
Which tree is the greener option?
To put things into perspective, real Christmas trees can produce a carbon footprint of 16kg of CO2 if thrown into a landfill, or 3.5kg of CO2 if properly disposed of via planting (if it has roots), wood chipping, or burning. The same size plastic tree would have a footprint of 40kg of CO2. You can’t argue with the numbers – real Christmas trees are much more eco-friendly.
Already Have a Plastic Christmas Tree?
If you already have an artificial Christmas tree, there’s no need to rush out to replace it with a real one. As with other plastic products you might already own, it’s always best to use what you have first. Make it last as long as possible to avoid any additional CO2 emissions.
When you’re ready to get rid of the tree, try to be responsible. Give it to someone who wants to use a fake tree to avoid driving demand for more fake trees. If it’s totally beyond use, check with recycling facilities in your area to see if they can take it.
Real Trees Are the Better Choice!
In the battle of real vs artificial Christmas trees, real trees win! But first, use what you already own. By decreasing demand for new products in general, you can help protect our planet this holiday season. Tip: this applies to decorating your tree, too! Check out our plastic-free holiday decor guide here.
We hope you’ve found this blog helpful! As always, you can support Aim Plastic Free by buying a cup of tea or sharing the site with a friend. Your support means the world to us!
Want more tips for living plastic-free? Sign up for our 30-Day Plastic Free Challenge and get a free calendar packed with simple steps to reduce plastic waste and live more sustainably. Make a difference, one day at a time!
